TL;DR: For many companies, 70–95% of the total carbon footprint sits in Scope 3. These emissions are not under direct control; they belong to suppliers, customers and product usage. Hard to measure — but you cannot reduce what you do not measure.
Definitions: Scope 1, 2, 3
- Scope 1 — Direct: emissions from owned/controlled sources (boilers, gensets, vehicle fleet).
- Scope 2 — Indirect, energy: generation of purchased electricity, heat or steam.
- Scope 3 — Other indirect: the rest of the value chain, organised into 15 categories.
The 15 Categories
Upstream
- Purchased goods and services — typically the largest category.
- Capital goods (machinery, equipment, buildings).
- Fuel- and energy-related activities (not in Scope 1/2).
- Upstream transportation and distribution.
- Waste generated in operations.
- Business travel.
- Employee commuting.
- Upstream leased assets.
Downstream
- Downstream transportation and distribution.
- Processing of sold products.
- Use of sold products — dominant in energy-using products.
- End-of-life treatment of sold products.
- Downstream leased assets.
- Franchises.
- Investments — the largest category for financial institutions.
Calculation Methods
The GHG Protocol Scope 3 Standard recognises four core methods:
- Supplier-specific: verified product carbon footprints (PCF) from suppliers. Highest accuracy.
- Hybrid: supplier data where available, average data for the rest.
- Average data: industry average factor × physical quantity (kg, m³).
- Spend-based: currency spent × emission factor. Easiest, lowest accuracy.
Practical strategy: start supplier-specific for the top 20 suppliers and spend-based for the long tail; raise the supplier-specific share every year.
Where Does the Data Come From?
- Purchasing / ERP: spend and physical quantities for Categories 1, 2, 4.
- HR / travel: Categories 6 and 7.
- Logistics providers: tonne-km for Categories 4 and 9.
- Life-cycle assessment (LCA): Categories 11 and 12.
- Supplier surveys / CDP Supply Chain: for supplier-specific data.
Common Mistakes
- "My suppliers don''t measure, so I can''t." Build a spend-based baseline first, then improve.
- Double counting. Draw a clear line between Cat-1 and Cat-4 to avoid duplicating the same emissions.
- Ignoring the use phase. For appliances, heating and electronics, Category 11 can be the bulk of the total.
- Running it in Excel. 15 categories, thousands of SKUs, hundreds of suppliers — not sustainable.
The Role of ETTA
ETTA maps ERP purchasing data to an emission-factor library, collects supplier surveys in a single interface and combines them with consumption/production data to produce CDP/GHG-aligned reports for all 15 categories. Every number carries a source and method trace — a defensible footprint at verification time.
Bottom Line
The uncertainty of Scope 3 is not an excuse — it''s a starting point. Measure roughly first, focus on the largest category, raise accuracy every year. In three years you''re ahead of competitors.